Utica rhymes with:
nautica, abacha, abadaka, absaraka, africa, america, anjelica, chanukah, hanukkah, indica, ithaca, japonica, majolica, nautica, oaxaca, seneca, silica, sunamerica, zeneca
Utica sounds like:
udagawa, utah's, utech, utke, utsey, uttech, utz