Totaled rhymes with:
totalled, totalled, battled, belittled, bottled, chortled, disgruntled, dismantled, embattled, entitled, mottled, nettled, prattled, rattled, resettled, scuttled, settled, shuttled, startled, subtitled, tattled, throttled, titled, totalled, unsettled, wattled, whittled
Totaled sounds like:
tailed, talitha, tallied, talty, tattled, telit, tilda, tiled, tillett, tilt, tilted, tilth, titillate, titillated, titled, toehold, toiled, toilet, told, toledo, tolled, tollett, tooled, totality, totalled